The Perfect Peanut Butter Cookie Recipe (Gluten-Free)

salted peanut butter and nutella cookie recipepeanut butter and marshmallow cookie recipe

In the mood to bake? Me too!

Try out The Perfect Peanut Butter Cookie Recipe (that just so happens to be gluten-free!)

I always feel like THE BIGGEST CHUMP when I bake regular sweets for an event and a gluten-free person is there. I feel like I’m saying “Sorry but these cookies/cake/brownies are delicious and you can’t have any!”

With the holidays right around the corner I like to make sweets for my boss, co-workers and friends so this recipe is a perfect inexpensive addition for all the events that will soon be happening.

Since I know a good number of gluten-free people I started researching gluten-free baking so the gluten-free-ers in my life didn’t have to be left out of the all baked goodness. This is what I found: all the gluten-free box mixes for cookies, cakes, brownies are approximately $6+ at the grocery store. That’s a lot of money for a frugal-living gal. So, what about skipping the box mixes, and making some goodies from scratch? In gluten-free baking this means: multiple exotic flours that I would probably only use like, once. Plus it’s a time-consuming process. So, no exotic flour adventures for this girl.

Get this, I stumbled upon a great gluten-free cookie recipe at, of all places, the gym. This is what I heard in my head, “Hey all you people, LEAVE THE GYM RIGHT NOW AND GO HOME AND EAT ALL THESE COOKIES LIKE WE KNOW YOU WANT TO.” So I did.

I’m all about versatile and forgiving recipes that are impossible to screw up. The recipes that are like, “Oh, you put in 7 cups of sugar instead of 1, and turmeric instead of cinnamon? It’s ALL good. We got this.” And then, boom, still delicious. Yeah, that’s the kind of recipes I look for, and this recipe is like that.

The Perfect Peanut Butter Cookie Recipe (Gluten-Free)

printable PDF of the recipe

Ingredients

  • 1 cup natural peanut butter
  • 1 cup sugar
  • 1 large egg, lightly beaten (or use one of these egg substitutes)
  • 1 teaspoon vanilla extract
  • Coarse sea salt

Directions

  • Preheat oven to 350 degrees F and place racks in the upper and lower third of the oven
  • In a medium bowl, mix the peanut butter, sugar, egg and vanilla until well combined
  • Spoon 1 tablespoon of mix about 1 inch apart onto un-greased baking sheets; flatten mounds with the tines of a fork, making a cross-hatch pattern on the cookies
  • Sprinkle coarse sea salt on top of the cookies
  • Bake until golden around edges (approx. 10 mins), switching the position of the pans halfway through baking; transfer to racks to cool; repeat with the remaining dough

Makes approx. 18 cookies.

Since there is no flour the peanut butter flavor really stands out!

Throw in whatever you have in your cupboards to add variety to this super versatile cookie recipe. I cut the batter into quarters like I did to experiment with a lot of different cookie options.

These are the variations I made (all gluten-free except where noted):

  • Salted peanut butter cookies
  • Salted peanut butter and Nutella cookies (the off-brand Nutella is just as good as the real stuff and comes in at $3; add 4-5 tablespoons of Nutella to the recipe; don’t mix completely so there is a swirly separated effect)
  • Peanut butter cookies
  • Peanut butter and marshmallow cookies – These are AMAZING! (add 3 rounded tablespoons of off-brand marshmallow cream ($1); don’t mix thoroughly; bake for 2 minutes less than usual)
  • Walnut, peanut butter, chocolate chip cookies (use your own discretion when adding in the nuts and chocolate chips, just be sure to leave enough batter to keep the cookies together; with this variation I keep them as little balls so they were nuggets of crunchy deliciousness)
  • Pretzel, walnut, chocolate chip cookies (not gluten-free)

pretzel peanut butter chocolate chip cookie recipesalted peanut butter cookie recipe

Happy baking!

What are your favorite gluten-free cookie recipes?

22 comments

in Food, Groceries, & Recipes, Social

16 Comments

  1. Meg // November 17, 2012

    Thanks Anna! I was recently told to go gluten free to counteract Hashimotos (immune system eating thyroid). I’m going to try these!

  2. Shannyn @frugalbeaut // November 17, 2012

    Your blog and pictures are just sooo darn pretty! Just had to give you some kudos and say I need you to teach me your ways! haha!

  3. Andi // November 19, 2012

    Thanks for the recipe!! These look great and I’m also gluten-free!

  4. Darla // December 23, 2012

    Thank you for this wonderful recipe! I wanted to make cookies for everyone for christmas and now no one gets left out!

  5. Cassie // December 23, 2012

    I’m definitely trying these tomorrow! Thanks for posting this :D

  6. Lucia // December 27, 2012

    I just made these and they are amazing! Yum, so tasty. Thank you for the recipe. Btw. mine are quite hard. Is there any trick to have them a bit softer or chewy?

  7. Nancy // December 30, 2012

    I tried these with Sunflower Butter & chocolate shavings…so delicious :) Thanks for the recipe! It was very to follow…which I need, lol

  8. Kristin // February 19, 2013

    Do you know how many calories ?

  9. Natalie // April 22, 2013

    Mine came out a little crumbly. Do you think I need to add a little more peanut butter next time? Or do you have any other ideas?

  10. Alison // April 25, 2013

    I made these last night for a vegan friend and substituted 1/4 cup apple sauce for the egg, they turned out very soft but very tasty, so this may be a good option for any vegan and gluten-free readers.

    • Anna Newell Jones // May 28, 2013

      Heck yeah! Glad it worked for your vegan friend. Gotta love easily adaptable recipes.

  11. Terri // May 28, 2013

    Yes! Finally someone writes about vet.

  12. Katie V // September 20, 2013

    The ones made with pretzels can be made gluten-free if you use gluten-free pretzels. Snyder’s of Hanover makes some. :)

6 Trackbacks

  1. […] Peanut Butter + Marshmallow Cookies (Gluten- Free!)- And Then We […]

  2. By a little bit of day to day « ifandany on December 12, 2012 at 11:04 am

    […] oreos shown above (there’s even a gluten-free version), and gluten-free peanut butter cookies below (on a frankenstein napkin left over from […]

  3. […] had the urge to make cookies, but didn’t have any butter at home and luckily found this great recipe.  Mine didn’t turn out looking quite as nice, but still very yummy.  It only requires four […]

  4. […] (Adapted from And Then We Saved) […]

  5. By Flour-free Peanut Butter Cookies. | Cakey Bakes on March 30, 2013 at 2:41 pm

    […] Peanut Butter Cookies slightly adapted from Anna’s website Makes about 20 […]

  6. […] when I found this recipe at the And Then We Saved blog, plus the many flavor variations she describes to make from one standard, flourless recipe, I […]

Post a Comment

Your email is never published nor shared. Required fields are marked *

*
*

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

  • Anna

    Hi, I'm Anna! I paid off close to 24k in debt in only 15 months & it completely changed my life! I want you to have a debt-free life too so here you'll be able to read all about: How to do a Spending Fast®, saving & making more money, DIY's, & a lot about living awesomely with less. Let's do this!

    Photobucket Photobucket Photobucket Photobucket Photobucket Photobucket

    Total Savings
  • Sign-up for Free Updates!

  • ModCloth
  • Featured On/In:

  • advertise on and then we saved
  • SPONSORS!

  • Categories

  • Archives

  • Search

  • Wanna Know More?

  • And Then We Saved® and Spending Fast® are registered trademarks.
    All Rights Reserved.